Committee asks candidates to safeguard courts' integrity, voters to realize judicial elections are different

By Charles Boteler
Chair and President, KJCCC

    Almost 40 years ago, with bipartisan support, Kentuckians amended our constitution to create a unified statewide court system with non-partisan judicial elections, ending a system in which judicial candidates ran under political-party labels. In 2014 Kentucky will elect all of its district, circuit, and Court of Appeals judges. In addition, four justices of the Kentucky Supreme Court will be elected.

   The Kentucky Judicial Campaign Conduct Committee was organized in 2006 as a private group to monitor judicial elections to ensure as best possible that our judges are selected fairly and in a manner that promotes the values of democracy and a free and independent judiciary.

   For the most part, Kentucky has avoided the bitter, overly politicized, and expensive judicial elections which occasionally have marred judicial selection in some other states, most recently Tennessee.

   In this election year the KJCCC makes two requests. First, we ask all judicial candidates to campaign in such a way that their campaigns positively support a court system that will be able to resolve, fairly and in accordance with the rule of law, the various disputes that will require litigation. Though some kinds of campaign activity may be constitutionally permissible, we ask candidates to refrain from the kinds of campaigning that sully the election process and even more importantly call into question the effectiveness and impartiality of our courts.

   Second, we urge Kentucky voters to insist that judicial candidates wage campaigns that focus on the issues relevant to the selection of a judiciary best equipped to function as an independent and competent court system. Judicial elections are different and Kentucky will be served best by judges free to evaluate fairly the evidence and legal issues in all cases that might come before them.

   Kentucky has selected its judges by popular election since the adoption of its third constitution in 1850. Popular election works best when candidates are committed to fair campaigns, and voters are committed equally to informed decision-making.

    In this important election year, the Kentucky Judicial Campaign Conduct Committee pledges it will assist in its role as a private monitoring group dedicated to promoting the values of a well-functioning, independent judiciary, dedicated to the rule of law.

Charles Boteler of Owensboro, a retired circuit judge, is president and chair of the Kentucky Judicial Campaign Conduct Committee Inc., a private, nonprofit, nonpartisan group organized to safeguard the integrity of the judiciary in Kentucky's judicial elections.